_karma_ wrote:
Wow, you don't have very strong feelings on the subject, do you? ;-)
Ok, a few things....
1) I read your initial post as painting with a very broad brush the need for the mediocre and as glorifying their role in society.
I simply happen to disagree. I think the mediocre are the reason our society has devolved. Simply put, you painted with a broad brush and generalizations so to keep things nice and simple, so did I.
This is where it's possible you didn't explain yourself well and I, in turn, fell prey to the same oversimplification.
2)
You: Our society would devolve into savagery if it weren't for yes-men and the unambitious.
I don't think it's too hard to draw the conclusion that this statement says anyone who is not a yes-man or who is ambitious will cause our society to .... what..... devolve into savagery. So to answer your own question
And where did I say that all ambitious, highly intelligent and capable people are assholes.
Just read your first post on the matter. It's not verbatim but I see no other way of interpreting the whole "devolve into savagery" thing. Ambitious, independent thinkers MUST be assholes if society "devolved into savagery" were they to run the show.
Again, I simply disagree that in order to be ambitious/smart/et al one must also be a prick and a savage.
3)
You: Part of the reason we evolved and became a society is because we've always had leaders and followers - not just leaders.
I disagree. I think we had a hell of a lot of leaders and just a few folks who didn't give a shit and were along for the ride. Thinking of colonial life, pretty much every pioneer, homesteader, trapper, farmer, blacksmith, rancher, etc was damn ambitious, capable, an independent thinker - and though most were not highly educated, if they were not highly "intelligent" in their particular area of expertise - they died! Nowadays we have the exact opposite problem. Too many dregs sucking off the financial/providencial teat of the ambitious. Too many who are simply sheep.... wait, I love mutton so I won't insult sheep... they're fucking lemmings and leeches and are the reason for why we are where we are today - financially busted inside out, militarily flaccid, academically retarded, physically (as a nation) slovenly, morally (and I have a rather unconventional viewpoint here so bear with me) bankrupt. If we had more leaders, we'd have a better chance of righting the ship.
And before anyone comments - I hereby confess to the Queen of the Run On Sentence, am often guilty of mixing my metaphors and get quite tangential at times. Get over it. ;-)
4) One of your arguments FOR lazy SOBs is that you need servants. Cool. I dig having them too. However, I refuse to believe that we need as many servants as the market currently provides. I could derail this by getting into my views on the Welfare and Nanny State or immigration issues but I'll try to keep it tight. The only reason we have so many lazy/mediocre people is because they don't die for being so - instead, they are rewarded and continue to breed more like themselves. There will ALWAYS be enough lazy/mediocre people to pour your coffee and shine my shoes. I just think we need a hell of a lot fewer leeches and a hell of a lot more leaders.
5) You mentioned you lots of unambitious sweeties who have no desire to tear anyone down. Good for you! I don't have that experience. Every fatty I know takes a negative attitude in one way or another to the fact that I am no longer so. Just about every idiot I know defends their lack of intelligence (often revealing just how dumb they are) and finds ways to minimize the accomplishments of the intelligent. Just about every _________ (fill in the blank) tries to tear down anyone more ________ than they. Now, I do agree that quite often the lazy don't lie there awake at night contemplating how to destroy their "betters" (trying to keep language simple here). Often they're guilty of destroying them through their own lack of ambition, lack of independence and personal responsibility, lack of understanding of their place in life. Ignorance is NOT an excuse! Sure, they may be super sweet, caring, loving folks. Nothing wrong with that. They can be fabulous human beings who, nonetheless, are a drain on society rather than net-zero or a contributor.
As to your "ordinary shlub" bit.... see above. Not to mention it was a preponderance of these ordinary shlubs who are responsible for the debacle that has become the White House. Just because the colossal maroons in the WH are getting the press, doesn't exonerate the maroons who put him/them there.
6) The juxtaposed thing... If you're following me on the above points (whether you agree or not, just try to follow me :) ) then that will probably be clear. Of course we all have different talents and abilities. The question is whether or not you use those talents and abilities to 1) support yourself and contribute to society or 2) let them lie fallow and suck the life out of this country.
7) RE: Competent people bragging/boasting. There is a difference between modesty and false modesty. There is a difference between bragging and simply stating a truth.
EX: I am smart and attractive.
This is not bragging because it is true - based not on my personal opinion of myself (ask my husband, I have "ugly/fat" days like anyone else) but based on my scholastic and career achievements and the fact that I get paid for my looks (near what the Obamessiah would consider "rich", thank god for write offs).
EX: I am not the smartest person around, nor the most beautiful.
This is not false modesty because I am not being self-deprecating as a passive agressive attempt to elicit approval. I am simply aware of my relative shortcomings.
As for what telling the truth and being appropriately modest "does" to those who are "less so"? Fuck 'em. If they feel bad about themselves in relation to me, that's their problem and they need to see a shrink or read some self-help books and learn to quit being so codependent and to generate some genuine self-esteem. Maybe they *should* feel bad about themselves. Maybe that's this thing society's tried to train us through the PC bullshit is bad.... is really GOOD! It's called 'healthy shame'. It's what you're SUPPOSED to feel when you fuck up. If you're a fatty, you're SUPPOSED to feel healthy shame that you supersize everything and share an artery with the couch. It's UNHEALTHY. If you're living off unemployment and barely scraping by when you could be out working 2 minimum wage jobs (but you make more on unemployment (fucktards in Congress) - you SHOULD feel healthy shame when I dance around ecstatically in my new Louboutins that cost more than your fucking rent. I EARNED my fucking money. Should
I feel bad because some shlub would rather live off the public dole?
And, on a final note, it sounds like we probably have similar views politically. Cool! We may just have very different views on the *necessity* of shlubs and the terrible evil that would occur if (remember that whole "devolving into savagery" thing?) if more folks were ambitious, etc.
Cheers!