The Intelligent & Relentless Pursuit of Muscle™
Beginners
 
Squats Make You Shorter?
1
 

Enray
Level

Join date: Jan 2009
Posts: 152

In the gym today after I finished squatting one of the trainers walked up to me and said "You're a tall kid, you might not want to squat or deadlift, you'll get shorter". Soooooo yeah, is that true at all? I know your spine compresses and decompresses throughout the day, but can it ever be permanently compressed?

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

TheDudeAbides
Level

Join date: Jul 2007
Posts: 3735

Enray wrote:
In the gym today after I finished squatting one of the trainers walked up to me and said "You're a tall kid, you might not want to squat or deadlift, you'll get shorter". Soooooo yeah, is that true at all? I know your spine compresses and decompresses throughout the day, but can it ever be permanently compressed?


Squatting compresses your spine and deadlifting elongates it. /sarcasm

I've never heard of that, but that also wouldn't prevent me from squatting again.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

Smallfry69
Level 2

Join date: Apr 2009
Posts: 442

Actually, there is some truth to this statement, but as you said, it's a temporary occurance that occurs throughout the day. The amount of compression from squats (his comment on deads is incorrect) would be extremely minimal (likely in the range of millimeters or micrometers).

I believe I read the same thing in a science journal about sleeping (the spine compresses during sleep), so according to the "trainer" you better stay away from sleeping as well...

Another example of how a little bit of knowledge in the wrong hands is deadly...

Squat away young grasshopper, squat away...

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

Rocky2
Level 2

Join date: May 2009
Posts: 1261

Smallfry69 wrote:
Actually, there is some truth to this statement, but as you said, it's a temporary occurance that occurs throughout the day. The amount of compression from squats (his comment on deads is incorrect) would be extremely minimal (likely in the range of millimeters or micrometers).

I believe I read the same thing in a science journal about sleeping (the spine compresses during sleep), so according to the "trainer" you better stay away from sleeping as well...

Another example of how a little bit of knowledge in the wrong hands is deadly...

Squat away young grasshopper, squat away...

The spine DECOMPRESSES during sleep.

But these guys squatted.


  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

Chris87
Level

Join date: Nov 2010
Posts: 1983

Enray wrote:
In the gym today after I finished squatting one of the trainers walked up to me and said "You're a tall kid, you might not want to squat or deadlift, you'll get shorter". Soooooo yeah, is that true at all? I know your spine compresses and decompresses throughout the day, but can it ever be permanently compressed?


Like these guys said, yea it does compress the spine, but it is minimal and goes back every night when you go to sleep. walking, running, and standing also compress the spine, a whole lot more then squats, as your usually standing for hours a day. For example, the average marathon runner is 1/4 inches shorter after a race then before it.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

SWAD1987
Level

Join date: Apr 2011
Posts: 112

unfortunately - NOT

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

marrot
Level

Join date: Mar 2011
Posts: 1300

I had this argument with my mom last week.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

Ghost22
Level 4

Join date: Mar 2005
Posts: 4231

No. People are fucking retarded.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

BONEZ217
Level 2

Join date: Feb 2007
Posts: 11473

The proper answer is "your a jackass, you might not want to say retarded shit; you'll get slapped"

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

HaveIronWillLift
Level

Join date: Mar 2011
Posts: 201

BONEZ217 wrote:
The proper answer is "your(sic) a jackass, you might not want to say retarded shit; you'll get slapped"


More helpful adice for a noob from BONEZ. Try to understand, this is not the street/prison. You can't slap anyone here. You're not topdog here. You're just a semi-literate moron.

And to the OP, back squatting does compress the spine. In fact the weight on your shoulders is only half the weight of compression your spine is under due to the floor pushing back with equal force. However the compression is due to the compression of the lumbar discs and unless you rupture one they will expand again immediately upon removing said compression. So no, squatting will not make you shorter but it may screw your back up bigtime unless you know what you're doing and you're careful.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

Just_Matt
Level

Join date: Jun 2009
Posts: 150

HaveIronWillLift wrote:
BONEZ217 wrote:
The proper answer is "your(sic) a jackass, you might not want to say retarded shit; you'll get slapped"


More helpful adice for a noob from BONEZ. Try to understand, this is not the street/prison. You can't slap anyone here. You're not topdog here. You're just a semi-literate moron.

Yet again, you've missed the point of someone's post. Were you raised by wolves?

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

Stern
Level

Join date: Feb 2010
Posts: 2385

HaveIronWillLift wrote:
BONEZ217 wrote:
The proper answer is "your(sic) a jackass, you might not want to say retarded shit; you'll get slapped"


More helpful adice for a noob from BONEZ. Try to understand, this is not the street/prison. You can't slap anyone here. You're not topdog here. You're just a semi-literate moron.


Read what he wrote again; it's pretty obvious who the semi-literate moron is here.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

get_ate
Level

Join date: Apr 2010
Posts: 89

A long time ago, I learned not to listen to trainers employed by gyms.

I suggest you do the same...

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

Dre the Hatchet
Level

Join date: Apr 2009
Posts: 2110

Tell the trainer to go kill himself. Or do it yourself. Harpoon him with a barbell or take a 25lbs to his skull.

You'll make the world a better place.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

PAINTRAINDave
Level

Join date: Jan 2010
Posts: 814

Dre the Hatchet wrote:
Harpoon him with a barbell


Oh, how I've dreamt of this. LOL

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

HaveIronWillLift
Level

Join date: Mar 2011
Posts: 201

Just_Matt wrote:
HaveIronWillLift wrote:
BONEZ217 wrote:
The proper answer is "your(sic) a jackass, you might not want to say retarded shit; you'll get slapped"


More helpful adice for a noob from BONEZ. Try to understand, this is not the street/prison. You can't slap anyone here. You're not topdog here. You're just a semi-literate moron.

Yet again, you've missed the point of someone's post. Were you raised by wolves?


Let's have a look at what he said:

The proper answer is "your(sic) a jackass, you might not want to say retarded shit; you'll get slapped"

- The proper 'answer' to what? The only person asking questions is the OP, so it could only be the 'answer' to his question/s. Not the guy in the gym who told him not to squat.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

lemonman456
Level 1

Join date: Nov 2009
Posts: 375

HaveIronWillLift wrote:
Just_Matt wrote:
HaveIronWillLift wrote:
BONEZ217 wrote:
The proper answer is "your(sic) a jackass, you might not want to say retarded shit; you'll get slapped"


More helpful adice for a noob from BONEZ. Try to understand, this is not the street/prison. You can't slap anyone here. You're not topdog here. You're just a semi-literate moron.

Yet again, you've missed the point of someone's post. Were you raised by wolves?


Let's have a look at what he said:

The proper answer is "your(sic) a jackass, you might not want to say retarded shit; you'll get slapped"

- The proper 'answer' to what? The only person asking questions is the OP, so it could only be the 'answer' to his question/s. Not the guy in the gym who told him not to squat.

Bonez warned you, now you're getting slapped. I'll be over in a few hours

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

JaseHxC
Level

Join date: Jun 2010
Posts: 1767

There's a shorter man who overhead squats in my gym...I should warn him immediately lest he be classified as a legal midget and has to runaway and join the circus...

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

herbs
Level

Join date: Jun 2006
Posts: 17

JaseHxC wrote:
There's a shorter man who overhead squats in my gym...I should warn him immediately lest he be classified as a legal midget and has to runaway and join the circus...


Ha ha Classic!

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

Kevin5255
Level 1

Join date: Mar 2011
Posts: 76

HaveIronWillLift wrote:
Just_Matt wrote:
HaveIronWillLift wrote:
BONEZ217 wrote:
The proper answer is "your(sic) a jackass, you might not want to say retarded shit; you'll get slapped"


More helpful adice for a noob from BONEZ. Try to understand, this is not the street/prison. You can't slap anyone here. You're not topdog here. You're just a semi-literate moron.

Yet again, you've missed the point of someone's post. Were you raised by wolves?


Let's have a look at what he said:

The proper answer is "your(sic) a jackass, you might not want to say retarded shit; you'll get slapped"

- The proper 'answer' to what? The only person asking questions is the OP, so it could only be the 'answer' to his question/s. Not the guy in the gym who told him not to squat.


says the nub who joined LAST MONTH to the guys with OVER 8000 POSTS

/argument


and to add, squats don't make you shorter they make you jacked

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

CrookedCrown
Level 1

Join date: Feb 2009
Posts: 207

HaveIronWillLift wrote:

Let's have a look at what he said:

The proper answer is "your(sic) a jackass, you might not want to say retarded shit; you'll get slapped"

- The proper 'answer' to what? The only person asking questions is the OP, so it could only be the 'answer' to his question/s. Not the guy in the gym who told him not to squat.


You, sir, are the perfect storm of troll. Either that or one hell of a smarmy fucking idiot... I haven't quite figured it out yet.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

xilinx
Level

Join date: Jan 2009
Posts: 345

get_ate wrote:
A long time ago, I learned not to listen to trainers employed by gyms.

I suggest you do the same...


Easy for you to say.. you got 2 spines in that avatar!

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
1