The Intelligent & Relentless Pursuit of Muscle™
Bodybuilding
 
Dumbbell Rows 'Widen the Trunk'
1
 

PChpm1
Level

Join date: May 2012
Posts: 8

For years ive had dumbbell rows as a staple part of my back workout, as i feel they hit a contraction lower down on my lats than other types of rows ie bent over rows. However, ive seen on a few threads that they arent as widely used as i thought due to the exercise "widening the trunk" (apparently Jay Cutler mentioned this a while back).

How true is this? I have naturally wide hips as it is, and I was looking for some opinions on whether this is the case.
Thanks in advance, from a new member.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

Iron Dwarf
Level

Join date: Feb 2008
Posts: 16335

A paradox?


lol


I doubt it would make that much of a difference, considering your lats are widening as well.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

kakno
Level

Join date: Dec 2008
Posts: 2764

I could live with a trunk that wide.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

PB Andy
Level 100

Join date: Mar 2006
Posts: 9590

well, first off I doubt you're at the development level where you have to worry about a 'wide trunk'.

But there is some truth to it. Yesterday I played around with Kroc rows/Chinese DB rows, and my whole left/right trunk (depending on arm I was doing) was spasming pretty hard to stabilize my torso while I row'd.

But still... not a big deal.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

buzza
Level

Join date: Aug 2010
Posts: 653

i'm with PBA about db rowz engaging the trunk (obliquus externus??),every time i switched from bb rows to db rows my obliqui are toasted heavy (doms for days).....

said this DB rows are my favorite back excercise,far more than bb rows as with db i can save my back erectors and focalize on lats,sometimes just for ego purposes i did bb rowz but very imo the fact that you use just one db really put the MMC on ,plus you can use a heavier load as your SNC (CNS)is less engaged,yes trunk muscles work more but just to stabilize the tripod (legs,hand on the bench),the fact is that the lat work even more with db rows..

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

FattyFat
Level

Join date: Apr 2008
Posts: 1365

DB Rows, performed unilaterally, of course, engage the core in an anti-rotational manner.
This is good and helps lay the foundation for a stronger core, thereby serving as prehab for spine issues, especially lower back ones.
Additionally, the lats have a stabilizing effect on the spine, too.

Performed correctly, this exercise is pure win.

As to the 'trunk widening' effect: as already has been stated in this thread, your lats grow wider (and thicker), too.
Besides, I daresay most people asking about such stuff aren't really at risk of having their whole packages ruined by widened trunks ;)

If your spine, especially your lower back, isn't stable enough, your body will not allow maximum force output of muscles anchored (directly and indirectly) by the spine.


  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

Iron Dwarf
Level

Join date: Feb 2008
Posts: 16335

FattyFat wrote:
DB Rows, performed unilaterally, of course, engage the core in an anti-rotational manner.
This is good and helps lay the foundation for a stronger core, thereby serving as prehab for spine issues, especially lower back ones.
Additionally, the lats have a stabilizing effect on the spine, too.

Performed correctly, this exercise is pure win.

As to the 'trunk widening' effect: as already has been stated in this thread, your lats grow wider (and thicker), too.
Besides, I daresay most people asking about such stuff aren't really at risk of having their whole packages ruined by widened trunks ;)

If your spine, especially your lower back, isn't stable enough, your body will not allow maximum force output of muscles anchored (directly and indirectly) by the spine.





Good post, FF.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

jwesus
Level

Join date: Dec 2010
Posts: 313

I've found with proper form my core/pbliques/trunk/whatever isn't engaged as much as if I just decide to go heavy.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

putter2712
Level

Join date: Mar 2011
Posts: 305

FattyFat wrote:
DB Rows, performed unilaterally, of course, engage the core in an anti-rotational manner.
This is good and helps lay the foundation for a stronger core, thereby serving as prehab for spine issues, especially lower back ones.
Additionally, the lats have a stabilizing effect on the spine, too.

Performed correctly, this exercise is pure win.

As to the 'trunk widening' effect: as already has been stated in this thread, your lats grow wider (and thicker), too.
Besides, I daresay most people asking about such stuff aren't really at risk of having their whole packages ruined by widened trunks ;)

If your spine, especially your lower back, isn't stable enough, your body will not allow maximum force output of muscles anchored (directly and indirectly) by the spine.



This. Also consider the limited hypertrophy potential of your obliques and abdominals in general, how 'wide' do you really think your trunk is going to get? Ignoring the distended abdomens of some Pro BB'ers how big have you actually seen obliques get? I dont think abs are a muscle you have to worry about 'overdeveloping' from an aesthetic point of view.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
 

hungry4more
Level 2

Join date: Nov 2007
Posts: 6749

You show me someone with overdeveloped obliques, and I'll show you a Greek statue.

  Post New Thread | Reply | Quote | Report
1